We have had an interesting Santa dynamic around here the last couple of years. You see, when Ben was little, neither of us cared to encourage the Santa story, largely because we felt it was about the gifts rather than the "magic." At the same time, when he came home excitedly telling us what other people had told him about Santa, we didn't have the heart to tell him that Santa wasn't real. And the same story continued with Will. We never told them anything about Santa because we didn't want to lie, but we didn't discourage it either.
Kate, on the other hand, has known for a long time that Santa isn't real. When she was two, she didn't understand anything going on, as she had only been home a couple of months. Then, last year at age three, every time she saw Santa, she would start screaming and crying, begging me, "Don't let Mrs. Claus get me!" I have no idea where her fear of Mrs. Claus came from, or if she was confused about who that was since we never bumped into the lady, but regardless, she did that several times last year. One morning after I had sent the boys off to school I sat her down and explained that Santa wasn't real and Daddy and I brought the presents. (And, yes, I also explained that this was a big secret, and to my knowledge she never spilled the beans.) She was relieved, and she thankfully stopped crying at every shopping mall we went into.
Fast forward to this year, and I thought we would play this out the same way. A month or so ago, Ben (age 8) started asking the typical figuring-it-out questions. He finally asked me point blank if Santa was real or not. I said, "What do you think?" He replied, "I think that if he was you would just say yes." But then a few days later, he was back to adamantly insisting that Santa was real. I knew that meant he knew but wanted to pretend, so I dropped it.
Then on Wednesday, Will (age 6) was in a bookstore with Mimi when they ran into the Big Guy shopping. Santa started talking to Will, but Will was dumbstruck. (Wouldn't you be, too?) Tonight we were in the van, just me and the three kids, and the boys started drilling me with questions about all things Santa. (Personally, I blame Michael Jackson's "I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus," which was on the radio, but it probably would've come up sooner or later anyway.)
Will: I
know that Santa isn't real.
Me: And why do you think that?
Will: Because the other day when I saw him at the bookstore, he had a wallet and was shopping. Everybody knows that Santa makes presents, not buys them. And why would he be here in this town anyway?
Me: Hmmm.
Will: And there were three of them.
Me: Three of what?
Will: Three Santas. One was ringing a Salvation Army bell. One was shopping and talked to me. And one was asking kids what they wanted for Christmas.
Me: You mean he was sitting in a big chair and kids were in his lap?
Will: Yes. So either they were following me around or Santa's not real.
Me: Hmmm.
Will: And once, I looked in front of me, and there was Santa talking to kids, and I looked behind me, and Santa was buying something. Definitely not Santa.
Ben: Well, I think Santa is in the North Pole with his elves making toys right now in his workshop anyway.
Will: And you know that Elf on the Shelf thing? He is definitely not real. There might really be elves, but the Elf on the Shelf is not.
Ben: How do you know?
Will: I felt of him once. He isn't real.
Ben: I think he is.
Will: The others might be, but not him. He is a toy.
Kate: Can we play Guess Who now?
Me: Umm, not right now, darling, the boys and I are talking.
Ben: Mom, is he real or not?
Will: Just tell us!
Me: What do you think, sweetheart?
Will: I don't think he is, but everyone in my class thinks he is real.
Ben: But what do they know? They're only kindergartners.
Will: That is true. They are kindergartners, and I am the smartest one.
Ben: How do you know?
Will: Because Mrs. T. says that my class is the best class of kindergartners, and I am the smartest in my class, so I must be the smartest kindergartner.
The conversation then devolved into an argument between the boys about whether Will's logic and evidence were faulty or not.
Once home, Will and I were alone, and the conversation began again. He reiterated that he did not believe in Santa. I said that was fine, but it was important that he not tell other kids that because it would hurt their feelings and make them sad.
And what is the first thing he does? The first thing he does with every single shred of information he ever has. He told Ben.
I went in to tuck Ben into bed, and he said, "Will told me you told him the truth."
Me: What I told Will is that if he doesn't want to believe, that is fine, but he shouldn't ruin the fun for others.
Ben: But that is pretty much the same thing as telling him Santa isn't real.
Me: I am sorry. Are you sad?
Ben: Disappointed. I was hoping it was real.
Me: I understand. I was really sad when I found out. I cried a lot. And I was really mad at Daddy John.
Ben: (Laughs at first, then gets serious) But why would grown-ups make this stuff up?
Me: I think they want to believe in magic because it is fun to think that Santa is real. It is exciting to think that presents will magically appear under your tree. And presents will still magically appear under your tree.
Ben: (Grins) But now I know where they really come from.
He was OK when I said goodnight, but I am more sad about all of this than I thought I would be. Don't get me wrong. I don't regret any of what I said (although some of the grandparents are probably
really mad at me right now). Part of it is that it takes me back to the day I found out, and how devastated I was. I don't think Ben is as sad as I was. And Will just seems satisfied that he was right about something.
There is more to it. Tonight my boys lost a little bit of their innocence. A little bit of magic is gone, and they won't get it back. Growing up is hard work, and I want them to be kids for as long as possible. All of this makes me realize how quickly they are growing up. I hugged them just a little longer, cuddled them a little closer, while they still want me to. Someday I will blink, and it will be gone.